Pianist Claire Huangci returns to Columbus Symphony with Tchaikovsky

Columbus Symphony Orchestra
Carl St. Clair, conductor
Claire Huangci, piano
Ohio Theatre
Columbus, OH
February 23, 2024

Wineglass: Alone Together
Tchaikovsky: Piano Concerto No. 1 in B-flat minor, Op. 23
 Encore:
 Gershwin/Wild: Embraceable You
Brahms: Symphony No. 4 in E minor, Op. 98

Last weekend’s Columbus Symphony concerts brought forth guest conductor Carl St. Clair, currently – and remarkably – in his 34th season as music director of the Irvine, California-based Pacific Symphony. Headlining the performance was pianist Claire Huangci, returning to the Ohio Theatre following a memorable debut two seasons ago. Prefacing the pianistic centerpiece was a local premiere by John Wineglass, perhaps best known for his work in television scoring – most notably for All My Children, garnering him six Emmy nominations.

Carl St. Clair, photo credit pacificsymphony.com

Alone Together dates from 2021, in the throes of the pandemic, and was premiered virtually by St. Clair and his California ensemble on the first anniversary of the murder of George Floyd. Scored for strings, harp, and percussion, it documents a challenging time in recent history (a recording may be heard here). The opening “Strange Pandemic Times” was marked by unsettling harmonics, though generally lushly tonal and reflective. A pulsating drum ominously sounded, taking a darker turn before the closing “A Ray of Hope.” The harp had a calming effect and introduced an appealing melody, but ultimately felt to this listener more akin to “feel-good” music than a work that fully captured the depth of the subject matter.

Tchaikovsky’s evergreen First Piano Concerto was a fitting platform for Huangci’s virtuosity. A bold, brassy opening pointed to the thunderous chords in the piano, but I found the pianist’s approach perplexing at best. She was wont to rapidly release her hands from the keyboard, almost as if the keys were hot to the touch. Not only did this make for an odd visual, but the tone yielded was rarely more than surface-level, inadequate to project over the large orchestra and throughout the cavernous theater – especially apparent in the rapid double octaves which came off rather feeble. Still, I found her technique impressive and effective in the elegant cadenza.

The Andantino semplice opened with pizzicato strings and a lovely flute solo. The pianist seemed at her finest in these more lyrical and restrained moments, including a touching bit of dialogue with cellist Luis Biava. The fiery finale was at heart a lively folk dance, likely of Ukrainian origin. As an encore, Huangci offered the great Earl Wild’s transcription of Gershwin’s Embraceable You – impressive fingerwork colored by sweet, jazz-inflected harmonies.

Brahms’ Fourth Symphony concluded the program. The work’s long journey embarked with a gentle dip in the strings. St. Clair had a keen sense of structure and pacing, though there was something to be desired with regard to balance, given that the brass were often too much in the foreground. The slow movement boasted some lovely string playing, contrasting the stentorian brass, while the scherzo saw jubilation amidst the work’s severity. Eight powerful chords made the spine of the closing passacaglia, its variations unfolding with dignified purpose.

Columbus Symphony explores Romanticism in Liszt and Brahms

Columbus Symphony Orchestra
Rossen Milanov, conductor
Claire Huangci, piano
Ohio Theatre
Columbus, OH
November 12, 2021

Williams: The Dream Deferred
Liszt: Piano Concerto No. 2 in A major, S125
 Encore:
 Gulda: Piano Play No. 6
Brahms: Symphony No. 2 in D major, Op. 73

As with the previous entry in the Masterworks series, the Columbus Symphony’s program on Friday night thoughtfully opened with a socially-relevant work by a contemporary African-American composer. Here, the work in question was the 2017 composition The Dream Deferred by Chicago native Evan Williams. Alluding to the Langston Hughes poem, the present work contends with how the American dream is all too often deferred for the Black and Latino communities, particularly amongst young males in what is chillingly referred to as the school-to-prison pipeline. Scored for string orchestra and harp, the piece is bifurcated into two brief movements, “it explodes” and “it dries up” respectively. The harp textures in particular showed the composer’s skill as the unsettled, ominous music proceeded until the titular dream eventually faded away into darkness.

A preconcert conversation between Claire Huangci and Rossen Milanov

The preconcert talk featured an informative conversation between music director Rossen Milanov and guest pianist Claire Huangci. The two first collaborated in Philadelphia when Huangci was just 12 years old. She was featured this weekend in Liszt’s Piano Concerto No. 2, a rather more lyrical foil to its more frequently heard predecessor. Plaintive winds were answered by gentle cascades in the piano, and the pianist’s elegant, sensitive playing captured one’s attention. Though certainly more subdued than the First Concerto, there were nonetheless ample opportunities for flair and virtuosity which Huangci delivered with aplomb, particularly in the riveting march. A ravishingly beautiful duet between the pianist and principal cellist Luis Biava offered a moment of calm before the big-boned finish. Huangci indulged the appreciative audience with an encore in Friedrich Gulda’s Piano Play No. 6, thoroughly entertaining in its jazz inflections and rapid-fire repeated notes.

The so-called “War of the Romantics” was a defining feature of nineteenth-century music, pitting against each other two vastly different approaches to composition. The present program intriguingly explored that by contrasting the Liszt with the latter half devoted to Brahms’ Second Symphony. The first movement opened gentle and genial, though it sounded as if it could have benefitted from additional rehearsal time. The trajectory of this expansive movement was not always clear as matters plodded along, with interjections from the brass fitfully uncoordinated and out of tune. Nonetheless, I found the slow movement more convincing with a serenity encouraged by the resonant cellos, and Milanov led the orchestra to a fiery passion before peacefully subsiding. Milanov aptly referred to the Allegretto grazioso as a “stylized minuet”, and it provided much charm ahead of the finale, certainly one of the most jubilant in the repertoire – just what was needed on a cold November night.